Sunday, September 25, 2005

Ibn Warraq Monotheism ultimately leads to facism ?

Ibn Warraq gets this point dead wrong as we have witnessed the Carnage and bloodlust of Communists who were atheists but proclaimed themselves God. The cult of reason in the French revolution also has to be reconciled with the Great Terror and the Colonial wars of Napoleon . Napoleon does not belong in a conversation with Communism or Nazism. Nazism was the cult of man deciding what life is worthy and has far more in common with Communism . The idea of sending humans to concentration camps or anyone else for that matter is man elevating himself to God.

The view that polytheists or Pagans were more humane then the monotheists is baloney.
The Mongols were certainly not peaceful animists. Ancient Greece was colonial and often imposed its culture on others. African and American Indian tribes were a mixed bag of peaceful and warlike tribes. This blanket statement is way too broad and the historical record is mixed at best.

10 comments:

Always On Watch said...

I also think that Ibn Warraq has this particular point wrong. Warraq is at his best when he is specific about Islam and doesn't try to analyze other ideologies; these particular analyses of his are indeed too broad.

I will say that any centralized religion as the form of centralized government is dangerous. That's one reason for having separation of church and state.

Polytheists or pagans were definitely not more humane than monotheists. In fact, monotheists led the way in the founding of this nation.

As Jason has pointed out many times, from its inception Islam has been political in nature--not just a religion of personal faith.

Mr. Beamish the Instablepundit said...

Islam isn't monotheistic, it's pseudotheistic.

Mr. Ducky said...

Question Beaker....what government created the first concentration camps?

Mr. Beamish the Instablepundit said...

what government created the first concentration camps?

Oooh! Oooh! Pick me! I know the answer!

You said "government" so this would exclude the semi-private enterprise of slave marketeering in the early Roman Empire.

I'm gonna have to go with the Caliphate of Abu Bakr in the late 7th Century.

Jason_Pappas said...

I agree with AOW, Warraq’s book doesn’t hinge on his view of religion in general since he builds his case on the specifics of Islam. You can take or leave what you want of the other points. I usually recommend it to people who are secular since some people wonder if Spencer, Trifkovic and others are coming from their religious perspective (they are not but I like having several sources.)

He argues more emphatically than I that Islam is a state religion created specifically for that purpose. I argue that it is a political ideology with religious trimming. Perhaps these two views are the same. In the 7th century, if you wanted to rule you needed the sanction of a religion. Presto: Islam.

Over on another website they are debating if I'm a racist bigot or not. This gets tiring. Some people just want to distort what you say. Fortunately, good people who still aren't convinced that I'm right (one Dr. Steele) respect where I'm comming from and know it is not from hostility towards any demographic group (never mind that Islam is not a race.)

Dream Builder said...

Great blog here! I'm definitely going to bookmark you! I have a opt in email lead site. It pretty much covers opt in email lead related stuff.

Come and check it out if you get time :-)

Marketing man said...

Hi, you have a great blog here! If you are interested, go see my advies email en language language marketing nl related site. It isnt anything special but you may still find something of interest.

Dotmotor said...

Can I tell your readers about good advertising on email marketing template Very thought provoking ideas in your blog.

Anonymous said...

Hey, you have a great blog here! I'm definitely going to bookmark you!

I have a ffa site myspace.com site/blog. It pretty much covers ffa site myspace.com related stuff. Plus you can advertise to billions using our ffa site myspace.com tools.

Come and check it out if you get time :-)

Anonymous said...

People are going to do what people do no mater what they believe. Always have. Always will.