Recently we had a visitor to this site who demonstrated my points about the left and their incoherent views of Jews, Israel and the USA. The policy of this blog is to allow and encourage posts. I do not back down from my assertions that elements of the left have devolved into a hateful clique. I encourage all leftwing Israel and Republican bashers to speak up. Your lack of civility, knowledge of history will be put on display for all to see. I respect honest liberals but this is a far cry from what we see daily. Real Liberals are patriotic and agree with me about open debate. The Radical left loves to place speech codes on campus. Dissent is fine as long as one agees with us. This is Orwellian logic right out of 1984 and has no place in America.
While this forum is open to all my opponent has changed the settings on his blog to a team setting. I am not afraid of his words or arguments and I encourage you come again and bring your friends. Bring them all here and express yourself on this blog.
Your lack of courage is typical of the left. I can not be a racist because there is no such thing as a Palestinian race or nation. The problem with the Recidivist is that he feels that all sources that disagree with his spurious points are tainted by Zionism.
Lets examine why this leftist has called me a bigot. He is upset because I claim there is no such thing as a Palestinian.There is no connection between biblical Philistines and Palestinians.The whole myth of the Palestinian is a moder creation after 1967. Prior to that the context of the wars had been Pan Arabism. The rallying cry was "Drive the Jews into the Sea ".
For more on these myths Http//:www.gamla.org.il/english/farrah/1.htm http://www.wnd.com/news/article.asp?Article_id=22564 http://www.rosenblit.com/palestine.htm
This new ethnicity does not have its own language. This new ethnicity has no history prior to 1964. This new ethnicity has the same religion as that of people in neighboring states Sunni Muslim. There is a simple reason for this Palestinians are the descendants of Arab invaders who colonized the area in the year 638 AD a mere 2600 years after the Jews were there. The fact is that Arabs are on real estate that does not belong to them in a variety of areas.
The Sykes- Picot treaty paved the way for Sunni Arab domination and created a series of bogus states. The people sold out in this fiasco were Assyrians and Kurds. All of the states in the region are creations of this treaty . Kurds and Shiites ware divided along illogical lines.
Lets compare Palestinians to these other stateless people. Kurds have a historical identity predating Islam and their own language. Assyrians are a mere 4000 years old have their own language and religion. Coptics are 4000 years old have their own religion and language. There are other groups with far superior claims Basques, Tibetians any Comanches .In fact I could do an entire blog on why Brooklyn NY has a greater case for nation hood than Palestine.
There is no connection to biblical Palestinian but if people like the Recidivist insist fine get out of the West Bank and move to the land of the Phillistines the Gaza strip. The connection to Cannanites is more absurd but coming from this crowd it is to be expected.
The left likes to talk about European Colonialism, American Colonialism and Israeli Colonialism. It does not say a word about Islamic Colonialism, Ethnocide and Genocide perpetrated on Jews, Christians and others. One can read about this topic in the works of Bat Ye'or or in Frederick P Isaacs Indigenous people Under the Rule of Islam.If Colonialism was evil when done by White Europeans it is doubly so when done in the name of Islam. The reason being is they are still on other peoples real estate today.
The sanctimonious left loves to indict Israel and America for its percieved crimes. Yet a simple book the Black Book of Communism shows the legacy of the left 100,000,000. There is debate as to what the Nazis were and there are certainly arguments that also place them among the left as well. I will leave them out for the sake of this post. The Recidivist ommits and neglects far more extensive ties between the Pseudostinians and Nazis. The ties were significant and part of a pathology of denial on the left.
Let us begin with the word indigenous. The Jews are the indigenous people and this fact is backed clearly by history and archeology. Palestinians are the descendants of Arab invaders who arrived 2600 years after the Jews. In fact Jews are but one of a series of indigenous people brutalized by Islam. A partial list of people brutalized includes Jews, Assyrians , Copts, Maronites, Zoroastrian, Hindus, Sikhs,Yezedis,Animists,Bhudists and a range of tribal people. In fact I challenge one to name a major religion that is not in historic or current conflict with Islam except Shintoism. Shintoism has yet to come into conflict with Islam. Jews, Assyrian Christians and Zoroastrians lived in peace amongst Hindus. How does Hinduism turn violent only when Islam is added. Jews lived so peacably in China they intermarried and converted. What ethnic group is causing problems in Western China ? We can go around the world and find mayhem bigotry and intollerance. The vast preponderance of ethnic conflicts involve Islam. Islam is in conflict with Bhudism and that religion is known for peace. The whole rest of the world is guilty of picking on Islam. Do you want to buy the Brooklyn Bridge. Take a trip to Freedom House and look at the freedom index Israel has a better rating than Turkey. The two most consistant variables with a poor rating are Communism and Islam.
Islamic Colonialism spread across Africa and Asia and Europe. Spaim was invaded in 710 and torture was used to intimidate Goths. Tariq Ibn Ziyad boiled prisoners in a cauldron and sliced other. (Alvin Schidtt The great Divide 45) We are suposede to feel sorry for the Muslims when Ghenghis Kahn employed similar techniques later. They were stopped in France by Charles Martel in the battle of Tours 732. They remained in Spain for the mythical golden age.This myth has been dispelled by Bat Ye'or . Scmidtt 47 Almost all the Churches were destroyed.6,000 Jews massacred in Fez 1033 and 3,000 more in Granada 1066. In 1126 the Christians were forcibly deported to Morocco. In 1148 the Jews were ordered to convert or be deported. We read about the Spanish Inquisition of 1492 but zero about similar measures caried out under Islam. In 1492 the Moors were kicked out a mere 700 years after they invaded. This is longer than the European Colonization of other nations. Yet we hear silence from the left.
Islam goes on to Colonize Europe except that the legacy of this invasion is still being felt in the Balkans tody.*Schmidtt pg 49 1351 Muslims invade Thrace 1361 conquer Adrianople.* 50 1389 Turks defeat Serbs in Kosovo. *51 for 800 years the Muslims try to conquer Constintanople 1453 it falls. 4,000 masacred, 50,000 sent into slavery.*53 The Muslims were stopped in Vienna twice 1526 &1683.
This is only part of the story it gets worse. However if the Recidivist insists on playing the Howard Zinn indict a civilization by its history game I will respond. Islam is the single worst practitioner on Colonialism , Ethnocide and Genocide in history.
Scmidtt Frequent Massacres of Armenian set the motion for the First Crusade. Turks commit Genocide on